At first I thought this question was a bit shallow… and I sort of think it still is… but at the same time, it’s kinda is a valid one.
For example, I can say that while I love my BF and think he’s the cutest thing in the world, his feet aren’t actually all that attractive to me. They’re not particularly meaty, nor are they skinny. The biggest problem is they can be very dry and flaky, and usually are completely odor free. Hence why I often use his (or my) shoes and socks instead.
So granted this is the opposite of the question you asked… sexy guy, not as sexy feet. And I make it work. So I’d think it could go the other way, too. But it’d have to be some pretty amazing feet. 😉