Wow, this is a great question. I haven’t spent as much time squishing food with my feet as I’d like. I will say I enjoyed bananas quite a bit… it was a good texture, and I love the goopy sound it makes when crushed. Same goes for peanut butter. And uh… I also had a very, very good time with a very large bowl of plain yogurt. Not just on my feet, either. Videos for many of these will hopefully be posted in the future. If I forget, please nudge me. 😉
I also did a pretty fun and hot video where I filled my shoes with Oatmeal and put my bare feet into them (which you can see here: https://www.tiedfeetguy.com/2011/10/post-1000.html)
Still yet to be done: the small chocolate pudding cup, some fun halloween slime, and a pound cake. I’m looking forward to gunging myself with all of them in the next few weeks, once I get more time.